Friends,
If we were seeking details about mentoring, we’d have to look no further than the relationship of Christ and His disciples. But, what we’re seeking here is a model of mentoring that we can take to heart for our own lives, given to us through the lives of other mere men. That story has been replayed many times through the history of the followers of God, and we could look at any of those examples.
Here’s my story.
People who’ve known me for long might assume that my ministerial mentor was my own father; I’m a pastor’s kid. But, God did not call me to a life of full time ministry during my father’s lifetime. While his example has often inspired and instructed me, I never had the opportunity to ask him the questions of the how and why of a life of ministry. I was only 21 when he died.
And, while I was 40 years old before God called me to full time ministry, my life has been enriched by an incredible string of mentors.
After my father’s death, I knew that my wife and I needed to change churches. My dad was pastoring a small church in Ponca City, OK when he died. As they looked to call a new pastor, I knew that they did not need me hanging around to complicate the process. Fortunately, my dad had recognized his situation and had arranged in advance for the pastor of a neighboring church, Ponca City First Church of the Nazarene, to come and get me. Reverend Dean Galloway gently approached me and let me see that connection for myself, and Margie and I made our way to that church.
I was a fatherless son at age 21, recently married to an 18 year old bride, and just getting started on the road to actually growing up. It was a tough time to not have a father. But, at Ponca City First Church of the Nazarene, God had a marvelous gift in store for me.
That was a church filled with older men who had much to give to a younger man seeking to become what God intended him to be. I can name their names and what they gave me, even today, 35 years later.
Frank Wilkerson taught me how to be a church supporter, in a financial sense. He trained me to be a church treasurer at age 22, and stood by me while I made all the normal mistakes. I learned that the church has more than enough resources, and that God allows us to be those resources, if we are faithful.
Royce DeWitt taught me how to really worship. I was the worship leader at that church for ten years. I was confident about being in front and pretty comfortable about leading the music. But, when I was uncertain of the actual state of worship in the congregation during any service, I only needed to look at Royce DeWitt to know where we really were. Royce was a quiet guy; his daughters all sang and I guess maybe he had a singing voice too, at one time. But it wasn’t his voice that trained me; it was his worshipping demeanor. When we were really engaged in worship as a congregation, it showed on his face. I learned that true worship was more than performance excellence, but was a matter of complete release to our heavenly Father.
Clarence “Bull” Mullins taught me that a Believer can function in the real working world. Clarence was a head operator at the Conoco oil refinery than would eventually employ me. It was a difficult place for a Christian to work, filled with obscenity and godlessness. But “Bull” Mullins was a leader of men in that place, and didn’t have to give up anything. He didn’t walk around with a “holier than thou” attitude; he was popular among the men there, but he accomplished that without having to lower his standards. He never acted like a super righteous man at church, and he never acted like a totally secular man at work. He was the same wherever he went. I learned that to engage the world, a Believer had to live a life that would work everywhere.
John Maker taught me to be a Believer in front of the community. John was a leader in our church, a businessman of good reputation in the community, a member of the Board of Directors for the local Salvation Army, and a Gideon. He taught me that a Believer can make a difference in the community. My community activism was never the same as John’s, but from him, I learned that Christians can make a difference in our world; we don’t have to be separated from it.
Lee Pierce taught me about being a churchman. My story with Lee is too detailed to include here, but suffice it to say that through some adversity between us, Lee Pierce turned out to be a person who genuinely passed the life of blessing as a churchman oon to me. I learned that God has a plan that’s better than the one I usually think I have.
But, the main person that God brought into my life was Harold Mullins. Harold was a farmer/rancher who was a leader in our community and a surrogate father to me. His family enveloped Margie and I through those first years and the births of our two older sons. They taught us how to be a Christian family and Christian parents. They ensured that we would never feel alone.
But, more than that, Harold Mullins convinced me that God had a significant plan for my life. He never pushed me toward the ministry; we had left Ponca City before God called me to that. He was never surprised that God HAD called me to ministry, and to this day continues to encourage me to move forward. I don’t talk to him very often any more, but I know without a doubt that every good thing that I am can be traced back to his confidence in me, his words of encouragement to me and the doors he continually tried to open on my behalf.
And, one much more important thing, Harold Mullins planted in me a lifelong desire to “pay forward” that relationship in my life. There have been two significant outcomes from that.
First, I have ALWAYS sought to maintain mentoring relationships in my life that hold me accountable for the person I’m supposed to be. We’ve moved many times, and I’ve spent time in numerous Bodies of Christ, some of them as the Senior Pastor. The first thing I have always been on the lookout for, however, was where I could plug in to some older man as a mentor for my life.
And, I’ve always found them. God has continued to place those mentors in front of me, when I sought them. They’ve often not been the most likely persons, but they’ve always been the right people.
I spent many a Monday morning drinking cinnamon tea at Hobie’s in Fremont with Al McNew. Al was guy who’d lived a long time, and not all of it as a Christian. He’d made his share of mistakes and learned from them all. He lived long enough to become a victorious Believer, and he did something that many such older men would be reluctant to do. He took a younger pastor into his confidence and told me the truth about the mistakes he’d made. He helped me, as much as any man I’ve know, shape the marriage relationship that my wife and I now enjoy, because he warned me about the pitfalls of marriage, many of them from hard won experience.
I spent a lot of hours with a guy named Ken Reese in Santa Rosa. Ken was a funny guy; he had lots of profoundly held beliefs, some of them actually correct. He liked to tell people what he thought. Some people veered away from Ken because he could really get in your face if he disagreed with you, and he often disagreed with me.
But, if you’d invest the time, you’d also find a man who was profoundly loyal to his friends and a true encourager. He was no “YES” man, but he never left your side when he disagreed. I learned to see Ken as a pretty good mirror of how I was coming across to the congregation, and he made me a better pastor.
I’ve had many peer relationships, as well, which have helped me to grow, and I’ve had times when I had to look hard for mentors, but this has all led me to the first great truth about mentoring that I believe every would-be mentee has to learn:
If you really want a mentor, you’re probably going to have to recruit him yourself.
You’d think it would be the other way around. You’d think that mentoring relationships should be created by qualified mentors, but that has not been my experience. The truth is that most older men believe younger men do not value their experience and believe they’d be rejected if they offered it. Many times, I’ve heard an older man my age say that he’d like to come alongside some younger guy having trouble, but they assume they’d be rejected and therefore never offer.
And, they’re probably right, most of the time. The greatest downfall I’ve seen in young pastors throughout my life has been the assumption that everyone older than them is a failure in life and therefore unworthy to ask advice from, except in not so veiled attempts to act humble. Every generation assumes that the world pretty much came into being around the time they came of age and younger people often discount the value of the voice of experience.
But, they’re wrong. You don’t have to be a success to be a good mentor; some of the best I’ve had taught me the most from their life failures. If you really want a mentor, you’re going to have to genuinely humble yourself before the voice of experience and ask for the relationship.
Most men are honored by that request, and few will reject it, as long as there’s some reasonable basis for it. This is no call for every aspirant preacher to run to the area District Superintendent and request that he be their mentor. There’s someone closer to your life that is capable to do the job and would be honored to do so, if asked sincerely.
How do you find them? That’s the easy part. You ask God to show them to you. It’s a prayer thing, and you stay with it until YOU understand His answer.
The Second outcome of my mentoring experiences has been a lifelong commitment to BE a mentor. II Timothy 2:2 (any version) tells you have this works. Here it is in the NASB:
The things which you have heard from me in the presence of many witnesses, entrust these to faithful men who will be able to teach others also.
II Timothy 2:2 NASB
This verse has long been a personal life verse for me and was quoted to me again by Dr. John A. Knight when he ordained me. I believe it to be the assignment for every Believer, and it becomes a vital message to anyone fortunate enough to have had an intentional mentoring relationship in their spiritual life.
The verse says it all; whatever you’ve been given, you’re responsible to give to others who will pass it on. Here’s the way that works out in my life.
I believe God has enabled me to be a mentor to seven men at a time. As a pastor, the second thing I look for in a new church is this: which men will be among that seven. The amount of time spent with each will vary, but the pattern never does. Here it is:
· When I find one of these guys, I commit to meet with him on a regular basis. (By the way, it probably needs to be said; men mentor men. Women mentor women. No variances on this rule, and every pastor should learn it and burn it into their heart.) That regular basis may be monthly for some and weekly for others. It may be coffee, a lunch, taking a walk or some other physical activity, but it has to be on a regular basis that is a priority for both partners.
· Every time I meet with my mentees, I ask them how I can pray for them; then I actually do it.
· I commit to pray for that mentee and his family by name on a daily basis.
· I make my list of seven priorities in my ministry. If I have a secretary, I give them the list and tell them, “If any of these guys calls, put them through to me. If I’m in a meeting, ask them if it’s urgent. If it is, pull me out of the meeting, without regard to whom I’m meeting with.” I share that commitment with my guys, so they know what it means to say their need for me is urgent.
· I ask only one thing from each of my guys. Once they’ve entered into this relationship with me, I ask them to be on the lookout for guys they can mentor in the same way.
Now, this is my pattern, and not necessarily replicable for every person. I don’t always have my list of seven full, in which case I’m looking and praying for the next guy.
But, while the pattern may vary, the principle does not, and here it is:
If you want to be mentored, you must commit to BE a mentor.
That opportunity may not come immediately, but it will come. From the time I spent with Harold Mullins, it’s been evident to me that God’s blessings are intended to be passed on. We are, and have always been, (Genesis 11; check it out) blessed to BE a blessing.
Always praying for you,
Pastor Joe